[Balin] The crimes, they are a-changin'

[BalinTheDwarf]

Peyton committed a crime, but was caught because he loved Reagan too much. How?
Peyton: H/A/M
Reagan: H/A/F

[doriana_]

Love = romantic love? platonic love? familial love? admiration for e.g. a celebrity?
Are Peyton and Reagan married? in a relationship?
Does Reagan know that Peyton exists? that Peyton loves her?

Is the crime murder? manslaughter? assault? theft? robbery?

Is Reagan the victim of the crime? a witness? an accomplice?
Does Peyton relevantly confess the crime to Reagan?

[Sundowner64]

Was Reagan alive when Peyton committed the crime? when he was caught?
Had Peyton not loved Reagan, would he also have committed the crime?
Was the crime committed in a planful way? Was Peyton's intention to help Reagan?
Relevant how much time went by until Peyton was caught? some months? a year? 5 years? 10 years? 20 years? more?

[Traveller]

Is she Nancy Reagan, former first lady of the USA?

[BalinTheDwarf]

Love = romantic love? This platonic love? familial love? admiration for e.g. a celebrity?
Are Peyton and Reagan married? Yes in a relationship? See prev
Does Reagan know that Peyton exists? that Peyton loves her? Yes to both

Is the crime murder? manslaughter? assault? theft? This robbery? And this

Is Reagan the victim of the crime? a witness? an accomplice? None of these
Does Peyton relevantly confess the crime to Reagan? No

Was Reagan alive when Peyton committed the crime? when he was caught? Yes to both
Had Peyton not loved Reagan, would he also have committed the crime? Yes
Was the crime committed in a planful way? Not really Was Peyton's intention to help Reagan? No
Relevant how much time went by until Peyton was caught? Assume no more than a couple days some months? a year? 5 years? 10 years? 20 years? more?

Is she Nancy Reagan, former first lady of the USA? No

[GalFisk]

Did his love influence his actions? The objects in his posession? Tattoos or other marks? Did he love her too much before the crime? During? After? Did she love him as much? Relevant?

[trebor2]

Did he give her some of the spoils of the crime?

[BalinTheDwarf]

Did his love influence his actions? No The objects in his posession? Yope Tattoos or other marks? No Did he love her too much before the crime? During? After? All three, but "during" is most relevant Did she love him as much? Yes Relevant? No

Did he give her some of the spoils of the crime? Irr

[GalFisk]

Did he relevantly leave something somewhere? Come back for something? Return to the scene of the crime? See the victim again? Relevant why he stole? What he stole? How? Where? When? Relevant what he did with what he stole? Did he also: threaten? Fight? Break in? Break something? Get hurt? Hurt someone? Did he use relevant tools? Weapons? Vehicles?

[Sundowner64]

Did he steal something for Reagan? a present for her? a personalized item? something with the name "Reagan" on it?
Relevant where he stole it? Did he pickpocket? shoplift? break into a house?
Did he call Reagan while he was stealing? did he send her pictures of the items? did he ask her which of the things to take?

[BalinTheDwarf]

Did he relevantly leave something somewhere? Yes Come back for something? No Return to the scene of the crime? No See the victim again? No Relevant why he stole? What he stole? How? Where? This; No to rest When? Relevant what he did with what he stole? No Did he also: threaten? Fight? Break in? Yes Break something? And Yes Get hurt? Hurt someone? Did he use relevant tools? Weapons? Vehicles? No to rest

Did he steal something for Reagan? Irrel a present for her? Irrel a personalized item? something with the name "Reagan" on it? No to these
Relevant where he stole it? Yes Did he pickpocket? shoplift? break into a house? This; No to others
Did he call Reagan while he was stealing? did he send her pictures of the items? did he ask her which of the things to take? No to all

[doriana_]

Does he leave something at the crime scene? on his escape route?
Was the thing he left behind a tangible object? more than one object? something non-tangible?
Did it contain identifying information? If so, did it contain Reagan's name? phone number? address? something else that pointed to Reagan? that pointed to Peyton?
Does he leave it behind accidentally? intentionally?

[BalinTheDwarf]

Does he leave something at the crime scene? Yes on his escape route? No
Was the thing he left behind a tangible object? Yes more than one object? No something non-tangible? No
Did it contain identifying information? Yes If so, did it contain Reagan's name? phone number? address? something else that pointed to Reagan? that pointed to Peyton? Most relevantly, these last two
Does he leave it behind accidentally? Yes intentionally?

[GalFisk]

Did it have their names? Pictures? Was it jewelry? A wedding ring? Did his love make him never want to be without the object, even when going a-burgling?

[BalinTheDwarf]

Did it have their names? Pictures? This Was it jewelry? A wedding ring? Neither Did his love make him never want to be without the object, even when going a-burgling? No

[doriana_]

Was it his phone? Did he have a picture of him and Reagan as his lockscreen?

[BalinTheDwarf]

Was it his phone? Did he have a picture of him and Reagan as his lockscreen? Got it.

****SPOILER****

Peyton robbed a house, but left his phone behind. His phone had a picture of himself and his wife Reagan as his lockscreen, which made catching him very easy.