Moderators: Balin, kalira, peter365, JenBurdoo, Tiger
Sundowner64 wrote:"we": a group of people? yes including you? yes residents of a town? a country? people from various locations in UK were involved people sharing a profession? a sports team? not these... humankind?
"would become a piece of history": still in 1999? in theory, straight away in 2000? after it became geography? history first, geography more relevant the following year much later? just now? well, it still counts as history and geography now and will continue to do so
"the following year": the year 2000? yes
the "it" that became geography: the same thing that became a piece of history? yes
"became geography": a new geographical object? yes a geographical object changed? no was renamed? named, not renamed geographical measurements were updated? I think so borders changed? no
Did maps needed to be updated because of this? yes
geography of Europe relevant? of Asia? of Africa? of North America? of Latin America? of Australia/Oceania? of Antarctica? of the oceans? of the world as a whole? Well... mostly UK really. For instance, most people in England wouldn't think Niagara Falls is relevant to them.
"piece of history" in the positive sense? yes negative? neutral? some folks might be neutral about it.
Sundowner64 wrote:The new geographical object: a lake? river? canal? mountain? island? village? town? district or other political unit? country? None of these
Is the geographical object real? yes, but poss FA did it come into existence in 1999? yes, but same FA in 2000? yes, but same FA later? does it still exist? yes
Is it within the borders of the UK? yes, England
Was there some other event in 2000 which turned the piece of history into a piece of geography? yes, although it was still history too
Sports relevant? no
trebor2 wrote:Mountain(s) relevant? no Is the geographical feature in England? this Scotland? Wales? Northern Ireland? Another part of the UK?
JenBurdoo1 wrote:Was it added to a map for the first time? yes, in 2000 A building added to a historical list? Idk but irr Was a blue plaque added to the building ("Such and such happened here in 1890")? no
JenBurdoo1 wrote:Is it relevant that the site was declared historical in one year, yesish but not put onto maps until a year later? yes Is this simply because maps take time to revise, idk, poss a factor but irrel or that the map in question was only issued in even years, or every decade? Was it considered historical in 1999, but not geographical? no, but... If so did circumstances change over the next year? something happened Did anything physical happen to the site between 1999 and 1990? Celebrities relevant? & no to the rest
trebor2 wrote:Y2K relevant? Any other stuff to do with the millenium relevant (even though I'm one of those who will confidently assert the millenium didn't start until 2001, and then will get booed out of parties)?no
The geographical entity: anything used to denote a jurisdiction where people live? (I know it was already asked if it was a town/village, but I'm not sure how pedantic to be here. City/hamlet/etc?) no If not, do we need to know exactly what type of thing it was? yes A road? A path? A trail? Is it something within a city?
Was a new geographical object constructed? yes Would someone looking at the thing think it was man-made? yes Is it meant to look man-made? irrel Is it a hill? Garbage dump? Does it have water in it? Is it a protected area? Environmental activism relevant? no to these
Did you make history because this was the first of its kind in England? Or in a certain part of England? The last of its kind? Does it take advantage of a legal loophole? Or a grandfather clause (apologies for using that term, but I don't know what else to call it)? Is it the biggest of its kind? Smallest? Some other descriptor like that? no to all
Everyone who created it, did you all share a common hobby? yes, for svv of 'hobby' Interest? this is closer Gender? Hair colour? Desire to get into the record books? Ability? Age range? Body type? Ideology? yes
Title of the puzzle relevant? yes
- and no to the rest
Sundowner64 wrote:Hippie culture relevant? not to the puzzle
Was there a relevant anniversary in 1999? no
Is the geographical object man-made? yope a bridge? a tower? a building? a monument? yes a canal? an artificial lake? an artificial island?
Was the object made/completed/brought into being in 1999? before? It was started July '98 and completed July '99, iirc
Did it exist unnamed until 2000? no, it was named in 1999 (at least officially unnamed)
Was the object named with reference to the process of its construction? Hmmm... can you reword? to the people involved? ditto to Hippie culture?
trebor2 wrote:Woodstock relevant? Another music festival?
Is the geographical thing a hill? Mountain? Forest? no to all
trebor2 wrote:I'm probably getting hung up on "geographical object". Is the monument a statue? A park? An area for reflection? yes Is it a monument to a person? To a fictional being? To an ideology? yes To a team? To your shared interest? yes
Sundowner64 wrote:Is the monument a religious object? some people would say so a church/temple/room no for prayer or contemplation? some people would
As per "yope" to man-made: is it partly man-made? a man-made object including natural structures? this is closest a naturel structure altered by people? is the man-made part basically that people gathered in this place? no
Is it sort of a camp? it took place at a camp
Is the object found in a city? in a park? in the countryside? yes in the open field? yes in a forest? possibly on the beach?
Does it still exist today? yes
Was it the first of its kind? (as the people "made history" in creating it) no
Sundowner64 wrote:Did people gather in an outdoor place to create the object? yes in July 98 and in July 99? or did they work on it from July 19 throughout Jul 99? on various occasions between and including Jul 98 and Jul 99
Was the creation of this object the intention and main reason of the gathering? That year, yes, although they would have gathered in the Julys anyway
Were more than 10 people involved? more than 50? more than 100? more than 500? more than 1000? 200-300 (guesstimate) on the July 98/99 dates. Other occasions varied, but I'd guess c.20-50
Did the people volunteer in working on that object? yes
Is the object the largest one of its kind? the first one in England? the first one with a specific quality? did it set a world record of some kind? no to all
trebor2 wrote:Was the object created by children? Teens? Adults? A mix? yes Relevant? Not particularly Was this part of a camp? yes, but the camp would've happened anyway
Is the ideology political? no Social? yes Something general that would give most people a warm, fuzzy feeling? (Such as Hope, Love, Peace, etc?) all, but irrel
... & also...
Sundowner64 wrote:Was the monument made of stones? this rock? or this - what's the difference? wood? sand? other natural materials? man-made materials?
Was it a youth or scout camp? no does it take place every year? the camp does
Was the camp on a regular camping site? no or somewhere "out in the wild"? not really... out in the countryside though in a natural reserve? a small one, yes in a place where camping was illegal? no
Did the government react in some way? Did they declare a protection status for this region? limit access?
Was a name or recognition status awarded to the monument or the site in order to recognize the effort?
Did it become necessary to add the monument to maps yes because people were searching for it? no, but OTRT, explore Did surrounding roads get blocked by visitors? Did local people get fed up by people asking for the way?
Did the camp get too big in 2000? So that roads needed to be closed?
Was public transport set up to the monument? so it needed an "official" name, so that the bus stop could be named? no to the rest
trebor2 wrote:Is search and rescue relevant? No
Was it added to paper maps? GPS? both Does it matter? yes Was it added to maps because people were getting lost going from the monument to somewhere else? Like they couldn't pinpoint exactly where they were starting from? no
Do we need to find out more about the ideology that you have in common? Not particularly, but here it is for colour: ... Does the ideology concern: the arts? athletics? philosophy? in a general sense eating habits (veganism, farm-to-table, 50 km radius, for examples?)? vegetarianism and veganism are common but not essential ethical consumerism? yes something to do with the natural world? yes technology? simplifying one's life? to some degree economic systems? societal systems? putting things on top of other things? scouting? geology? climate change? to some degree
... Basically, all the things you might expect hippies to be interested in.
Is the monument a henge? YES Does it take a relevant shape? Is it over ten feet tall? I think the two gateway stones are about 8 to 10 feet tall. The others are smaller. Over twenty? Fifty? Is it meant to resemble something? other than a stone circle, no. Is it a cairn? Burial marker? No, but you might be interested to know that under each stone is the skull of a different animal (who died of natural causes). Irrel.A trail marker?
Sundowner64 wrote:Is it a replica of Stonehenge? no
Did it need to be indicated and named on maps because tourists were thinking it's the real Stonehenge? no
Biograd1 wrote:Did it take a year to be added to the map because nobody except for the group of hippies who created it knew of its existence until then? Broadly, yes. Was the location of the hippies' camp itself a secret because you didn't want outsiders to bother you? no
trebor2 wrote:Did someone involved in building the henge have a connection to a map-making/satnav/census organization? Did the henge receive news coverage? Did somebody outside of the group stumble upon the henge? Yes Was there some work going on surrounding other henges? Perhaps some documentary work about historical henges, going into the year 2000?
Was something else slated to be built nearby? Roadwork relevant? Permits?
Is the name of the henge relevant?
No to the rest
Biograd1 wrote:Did a hiker/biker/other person performing outdoor exercise/recreation stumble upon the henge? a professional in the course of performing his/her job? yes did someone see it from the air when flying over it in aircraft yes (this was before the time of drone photography, but maybe a low flying plane saw it)? and yes
Return to Solved Lateral Thinking Puzzles
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest